It's Hard to Hide
The digital trail is simply too great to avoid
eventual discovery. The corollary is that we moving to a world
where we accept that a significant proportion of woman are
genetically XY and significant proportion of men are genetically XX.
And another significant proportion are gender neutral.
A pertinent statement was made by Talisa Garcia - who was outed as a
transwoman by
a UK newspaper in 2005 after an affair with a celebrity: "Everyone has
skeletons in their closet - only mine is bigger than most."
In 2020 Talisa appeared a leading actress in the TV series
Bapitiste, playing Kim Vogel who is revealed to be a
transwoman!
Six examples of 'Selfie' photos
posted by transwomen on their social media accounts
and subsequently widely shared. Three are by openly transgender women,
the other three are by transwomen apparently trying to
go stealth as they had removed trans indicators from
their profiles.
|
|
|
This innocuous photo (left) of four female friends on
the beach was posted on a social media site.
However, it was soon spotted that the girl on the right
had an Adam's Apple and obvious breast
implants. A few hours later she was identified as a French transwoman. |
If
you are stealth, it's not a great idea to go out
in public with two friends who are openly transgender.
It's an even worse idea to pose for photos for a
passer-by! |
Over the last few years, a dozen or more girls have asked me for
whatever reason to remove their photos and information from this
website, but despite the clearly determined efforts of some, it's a
simple exercise to disprove the possibility that all evidence of
their transsexuality had really gone from the web.
Maurizia Paradiso (centre) in an episode of
Colpa Grosso in 1991
|
Television
Maurizia Paradiso is an Italian transwoman. By age 23
she had transitioned and was performing as a "transvesti" in
nightclubs, in 1988 she had SRS age 33 and went stealth.
She spent the next two years working in erotic telesales
with some success - and in 1991 she become the
host of the notorious (due to it's semi-nudity) but very popular game show Colpa Grosso
("Big Shot"). In one episode contestants
had to identify in the "Big Question" which of the bevy of increasingly scantily
clad young women
parading on stage was a transsexual. The slight twist was
that it was actually the presenter
- Maurizia.
In
more recent years, television
has developed a passion for including a transwoman in every reality TV series – with the lady
in question ideally being very passable
before eventually being out’ed in some way.
The genesis of this probably occurred in early 2004 when Sky
broadcast to the UK a reality TV series called There’s
Something about Miriam.
This
involved six male contestants spending three weeks at
a villa in Ibiza trying to woo a pretty 21-year-old Mexican
pre-op transsexual woman called Miriam Rivera in order to
win the prize. Only at the end were the supposedly
shocked contestants told about Miriam's "something",
although from previously shown conversations they clearly
had an increasing suspicion. The contestants then began a legal action
against the producers claiming conspiracy to commit sexual
assault. Their lawyer said: "The men had no idea that Miriam
was a transsexual. ... They are horrified because there are
shots of them snogging, cuddling and groping her." Sky
settled the case for £125,000 ($200,000) each.
A
few months later, the fifth series of Big Brother UK
started. 27-year-old Nadia Almada was a popular
housemate who ceased to worry about hiding her generous
buxom
from her fellow contestants as the days past. But she did keep secret the fact
that she was a post-SRS transgender woman - although viewers
were informed. After 71 days in the Big Brother house, she
emerged as the winner, securing a massive 74% of the votes and
winning £63,500.
These two programmes set a formula that has been used
numerous times since, a few more examples from the UK:
In 2015, MTV's Ex on the Beach
Season 3
included
Larissa Alicia Summers as the cast member 'Laura'. She
had been outed as a post-SRS transwoman by newspapers in 2009 when working as a
pin-up model, most viewers soon knew this so it was no real
shock when another
contestant called her "a man".
In 2019, Channel 4, showed in the UK the short series
Gender Quake. Eleven strangers of different gender
identities and sexualities shared a house for a week. Given
the nature of the programme, it wasn’t a great surprise
when 23-year old
Cambell Kenneford
(left) revealed that she was a post-SRS transwoman but her
housemates seemed awed by her passability, from a shared
bedroom to the hot tub.
Finally,
the
BBC 3 reality series Heartbreak Holiday - also shown
in 2019 - followed the amorous adventures of ten
20-somethings on a month-long vacation in the Greek islands.
Maxine Heron (age 24) introduced herself to viewers as a
transwoman at the start of episode 1. But she was
completely passable and it was half-way
through the series before she announced to her surprised companions that she
was “trans”, having transitioned age 16.
Emel Aydan, born in 1951 as Erdoğan Kaşif
(inset), is a Turkish
porn star who appeared in many films in
the 1970's - often co-staring with her
stepmother in films directed by her father! It was never
hinted that Emel was a
MTF transsexual. |
Sexual Intercourse
Sexual intercourse can be a give-away for a transsexual woman,
particularly when partnering with a sexually experienced man - often
the hunky and masculine type that a newly post-SRS woman is seeking
out. Possible
problems include any of: obvious scare tissue; a vulva with a
strange appearance; vaginal hair; a bad smell, the vagina entrance
is oddly positioned, the vagina is tight and narrow, unsatisfactory
depth; and a lack of lubrication.
A few transwomen are lucky enough to meet a "true
love" whilst still pre-op. Her sex reassignment surgery can then be shared
experience, and the subsequent intercourse "wonderful", no matter how
bad it actually is! In practice, most transwoman break their
virginity as a woman with an experienced heterosexual man. If
he's unaware of her past, this poses significant risk, particularly
if she is at an age where sexual inexperience as a female might seem
very strange.
A social media picture posted by Deana O'Riordan
|
Thankfully with modern surgical techniques the chance of
an immediate exclamation of "Oh my god, what is that" by the man on
seeing his FTM partners vulva has decreased
very considerably in recent years. Going further, the happy coincidence
of a pelvic girdle (bones) with
intermediate sexual proportions and a good result from a top surgeon
will leave male lovers very contented and some natal women
very jealous - but this is a best case.
A typical case is Deana O'Riordan, born Dean. She had GCS and
breast augmentation just after her 21st birthday. She
was now was extremely passable and went stealth. Thereafter
she sex with many boyfriends, not revealing her past on the basis
that:
"It's none of their business ... If a guy can't accept me for me, why would I want to be with him? If I’m just having fun like a normal girl would in their 20s, then I
don’t have to explain. There’s no difference physically between me and a girl. If they can’t tell the difference, why should I tell them?”
However some partners suspected after intercourse that she transsexual and dropped hints, and finally one confronted her about this, leading her being outed age 25.
A very passable transwomen are out'ed due to poor quality
'bottom' surgery. |
In another example, the British comedian Bob Monkhouse relates in his
autobiography Crying with Laughter how after a show he was
approached by a buxom and "beautiful blonde dancer from the chorus line"
and "one dinner later enjoyed a night of passion".
However, her vagina gave him no
satisfaction, he described the feeling during intercourse as being mushy and blocked, "it was like plunging your feet into an apple-pie bed".
At breakfast the next morning the poor girl admitted to him that she had recently had a
sex change operation, and that he was the first man she had ever had
intercourse with. Bob then belatedly remembered him/her
from the male chorus line at his show in Glasgow a few months
earlier. Bob is reasonable about this (at least in the book),
but many men might not be.
Top, a 2014 photo
from Sun Jing-Ya's Facebook site, below the photo on her
still male ID card,
dated 2009. |
An opposite to Bob's girl is the story of
Sun Jing-Ya or 'Linda'. Born in China in 1989 as a boy, Luo Yue, she worked the streets for several years as a shemale to fund her
sex-reassignment surgery which she had in 2012, age 22. She then quickly
became renowned for her sexual skills and techniques as a woman, and
within months was able to charge VIP's $3000 for a one-hour session!
Prostitution is illegal in China and her success eventually led to
her being arrested in 2015 and being made an example of. At
her trial it was claimed that she had been paid nearly
$100,000 to attend a three-day orgy with wealthy businessmen.
The trial
initially
proceeded on the basis that Linda was a natal cis-woman, until
the prosecution unexpectedly produced evidence showing that she had
been born male -
undoubtedly to the shock of many of her former clients, 67 of whom
were cited! She
was jailed for four years.
Whilst
the above stories are worrying, in practice many recently post-SRS
woman are eager - even frantic - to have sex with a
man after their GRS. It might not be Romeo and Juliet,
but they want to build up sexual experiences comparable to women 10, 20 or
even 30 years younger. A common method is to have one-night
stands with a drunken but horny young man at a night club - even a
mature and unattractive woman has a good chance at the end of the
night if sex is on offer for free.
The 1978 semi-documentary
"Let Me Die a Woman" has many
faults, but the scene showing a transwoman (probably an actress)
facing the consequences of having sex too soon after her SRS/GRS
is still relevant. |
Bob's anecdote hints at a common problem, prematurely having
vigorous intercourse can cause serious damage to a neo-vagina.
Surgeons generally recommend at least a six-week delay before having
intercourse after surgery, but one study found that 1 in 5
transwomen have intercourse before that - usually voluntarily but
sometimes after intense pressure from their partner.
A
stealth transwoman
trying to break her virginity as a woman via a one-night stand
really need to wait at least six months after surgery. By
that time the scars from the surgery will have faded significantly
whilst the pubic hair will have regrown, so being viewed naked under
bright lights or even in the morning daylight will hopefully not be a disaster.
Also, six months of vaginal healing,
dilation and post-natal exercises, perhaps combined with a little bit of
rehearsal with a dildo whilst watching porn videos will help to give
him a good sexual experience - and hopefully herself as well when
nervousness fades.
Whilst a disappointing vagina is the most common
give away during sexual intercourse, obvious and poor quality
breast augmentation doesn't help.
A variant of this problem is Gemila, who had SRS age 36. She
then led an active sex life
with multiple male partners
for several years with no problems, but one night in bed her
boyfriend suddenly said "you're a transsexual man, don't deny it".
He had the terminology slightly wrong, but she didn't deny it.
The giveaway was that her unaugmented breasts
were far too pert and teenage-like for a woman of about 40. Puzzled,
he did some research on the internet and discovered that Gemila's small areolae
and breast shape was typical of a
transwoman - and some other physical characteristics and problems that
Gemila had then suddenly made sense to him.
If you are a transwoman -
don't get ill on holiday! |
The Medical Barrier
A huge problem for transwomen going stealth is the
impossibility of passing many medical tests and examinations as a
natal woman. For example, even the most minor procedure or
test will require the completion of forms asking questions such as:
|
Most of these transwomen went
stealth after this photo was taken. But it still often
appears on-line, so I feel able to include it here.
|
Not completing the forms correctly is risky - both
medically and legally. For example, I had a medical emergency
when I fainted from dehydration and heat stroke whilst on holiday.
My holiday insurance company refused to payout as I had not revealed
that I was transgender, even though this was completely irrelevant
to the event. I ended up nearly $5000 out of pocket.
I entered the Irish
public health care system age 39 when I needed to get my hormone
prescriptions renewed, which my local doctor (GP) thankfully did
with a minimal of fuss. I then bumbled along for many years
until as a woman who had reached a certain age I
started to receive letters inviting me to have smear tests and
breast mammograms. The former I decline but the mammograms I
feel are essential, but they always involve an embarrassing
conversation when I have to say that I'm a
transwoman.
In another example, 29-year-old Mathilda had been
stealth for a decade after her transition
and surgery. Whilst a clinic prescribes her hormones she
uses her local doctor for minor illnesses. On one visit the doctor decided to do a
blood test - two days later she got a call from a nurse saying,
"Your blood test came back abnormal. Are you sure you are
not pregnant? When did you last have a period?" She
had no choice but to reveal that she was a transwoman, and she is
certain that this led to her employer also discovering this.
Over Confident
Transwomen Being Outed
I can't resist
including this photo from the
2012 Miss Transsexual
contest
held in Pataya, Thailand. The tuck of the girl in the
centre has failed and an erection is very obvious!
|
Some transsexual women who achieve deep stealth then seem to have an urge to "play with fire" and
start to take ever increasing risks. For example: starting to
revisit old haunts, taking on a job or role with a high public
profile, excessive surgery, an affair with a celebrity, posting
topless or even nude photos on the internet, becoming a politician,
making false claims that are easily to checked.
A common problem is becoming too confident in your ability to pass
physically. For example, Eve was already stealth when she had
SRS age 20, and subsequently led a very active sex life with men
without any problems. She then unwisely posted online a "soft porn" video
of herself with a male partner. Viewers quickly identified
that she was a transwoman and she was outed.
In the
early 1990's
Lana Woods, a post-SRS transwoman, was the lead female star in several porn films.
The producer allegedly didn't know her male past but Lana eventually made the
mistake of confiding to a make-up artist, who leaked her story.
Jan looking at a picture of his wife Monica in happier days. |
Indonesian born Monica is another example of over
confidence. She had SRS at a young age and went stealth
when in 1993 she met and soon married a Dutch man, Jan, who was
nearly twenty years older.
She moved with him to the Netherlands and they were happily married for
19 years, until Jan discovered in 2012 that his wife was
advertising herself on-line as being available for sex with young men.
In
addition, some of her customers commented in reviews that she was a
post-SRS transsexual rather than a natal cis-woman.
Jan confronted his wife who admitted she had indeed been born a
man. He
had never suspected anything -
Monica took contraceptive pills (she didn't want kids and he
had accepted this) and every month she apparently had a period and used sanitary
towels. The only slight giveaway in Jan's hindsight was
the need to use a lubricant when they had sexual intercourse.
Jan then sought to have the marriage annulled, claiming 'I feel I've been assaulted
[sexually]' but this was denied as
the Netherlands recognises transwomen such as
Monica as
legally a woman, and the marriage was thus valid.
As of 2015, Jan and Monica are still technically married and
they even still live in the same house, although apparently
rarely speaking.
Victoria Beltran with Admiral General Aladeen (aka Sacha Baron Cohen)
in the The Dictator (left), and 'guarding' him at a publicity event
(right). |
A high-profile case is the story of Victoria Beltran.
She was probably born in February 1979 - although 1987 is
stated in some press reports. It's likely but not
certain that she transitioned and became Victoria
when she moved
to New York
in 1993,
age 15, and had SRS age 18. She then went deep stealth,
working occasionally as a model (e.g. Maxim Magazine, Dior, L’Oreal)
and an extra in TV shows (e.g.
Law
& Order and Ugly Betty). In 2009 she married
Brett Bergman, who was allegedly unaware that she was transsexual.
In 2011 Victoria
was selected
to be one of the mini-skirted "Virgin Guard" in Sacha Baron Cohen’s
movie The Dictator, appearing
briefly
in the movie and more prominently at subsequent PR events in 2012.
Reporters were already checking her past for other reasons and she became worried that
she would be out'ed being a transwomen, and this indeed
occurred in a NY Times article in May 2012. Her shocked husband sought comfort
with a female work colleague, Katarzyna Sakowicz, and they began an
affair. Victoria discovered this and
started to make threatening phone calls to Katarzyna, who eventually
contacted the police - resulting in Victoria being arrested in May
2013 on harassment charges. Victoria then said “I’m more a woman than she’ll [Katarzyna] ever be!”, and
claimed
that her
husband actually "knew the whole time” about her past.
Her husband has since filed for divorce.
Clare Killman is openly
a transwoman and seeking public office. Photos
with her much taller and robustly built boyfriend
help to emphasise her
femininity and physical passability. (USA)
|
Downside from Stealth
There are many potentional unexpected downsides from living in
stealth. One example is Brianna, born Brian she had
successfully transitioned to female and gone stealth age 20.
25 years later she was in her second mariage when she discovered
that an uncle had passed away, leaving Brian a substantial sum of
money. She lacked the documentation to prove to the
satisfaction of the Executor that she was Brian, whilst trying to
obtain this would
probably have
out'ed her and wrecked her marriage.
Transwomen Outing Themselves
Some stealthy transsexuals eventually
decide too 'out'
themselves. This seems to be particularly common among transwomen who
successfully transition when young and have a successful life and
career as a woman, but in middle age decide to come
out as being a transgender woman.
A few examples include
Lynn Conway,
Aleshia
Brevard and Anna Taylor. But there are also younger examples
such as model
Teddy Quinlivan, entertainer Corey Rae and social media 'influencer' Michelle
Alexandra.
Michelle (shown right) was born a boy- Mitch - and says:
My childhood was very confusing, as you can
imagine being born as a boy but thinking, acting and feeling like a
girl was a lot for little 4 year old me. I remember feeling so
relieved when I picked up a magazine and read an article about the
legend [Kim Petras] . She was 14 years old and transitioning. I
remember clearly running over to my Mum super excited and somewhat
relieved screaming “MUM THIS IS ME, THIS IS ME!” From that day
forward my real journey began, my parents took me to our local GP
and the rest is history!
Nadia Almada
(right)effectively outed herself by entering Big Brother UK
2004.
Lisa du Preez, age 32 |
Michelle started taking estrogen hormones age 14, had her first breast augmentation age
17, and gender reassignment surgery age 18,when she went stealth.
As a curvaceous and well-endowed young woman, she built
up a substantial following on social media and made a reasonable
living from this, including many trips to exotic locations with her
admirers. But there were increasing rumours that she was
transgender. In January 2023, age 27, she outed herself as a
transwoman.
It is not certain if
Michelle sold her story - although it first prominently featured in the
Daily Mail newspaper. There are however many instances where stealthy transwomen appear to have decided
for financial reasons to sell their story to the media, examples in
the UK include Nadia Almada,
Angel Paris Jordan, and
Lisa Du Preez.
Nadia (born Jorge
'Carlos' Leodoro in 1977) transitioned when she moved to the UK from
Madeira in 1999 and had her SRS a few years later. She
won a £65,000 prize by
intriguing housemates and television viewers when, age 27, she
participated in the UK version of television reality show
Big Brother in 2004. She went into the house
stealth, but housemates began to wonder if she was TS after just a few days.
The program's producers already knew that she was a transsexual, and soon the
rest of the world did as well.
Jackie
McAuliffe, age 28 |
A second example is Lisa du Preez (née Ward).
Her story from boy to woman appeared in various newspapers and
magazines with tabloid suitable quotes such as a News of the World headline in July 2009 -
"Lingerie model
Lisa was
once a man called Louis (and her boyfriend didn't know)".
Another story said "When I met my fiancé ... in a pub a
year ago we hit it off right away but I didn’t tell him about the
surgery."
Jackie McAuliffe
is perhaps an extreme example of this. Born Jason, she
transitioned age 20 and had SRS when 25. She was fortunate to
then be totally passable as a woman, and in the late 1990's she worked
for several years as a female prostitute - sleeping with hundreds
of men. But she was very publicly outed (albeit presumably
with Jackie's consent) in the BBC real life docu-drama Paddington Green
in 1998.
The BBC paid her very little and a new career as a musician quickly
came to nothing; she readily admitted to financial difficulties in
the follow-on program Jackie's Story. Since then she has
married and changed her name, the passage of time and a low profile
life style has allowed her to slip back in to stealth.
A slightly
different example of the potential issues
is Sarah Green.
She transitioned age 17
and was initially
successfully
passing and developing as a young woman
- "it was brilliant too. I wasn't hiding anymore". She
wanted other young transsexuals to know that "they don't have to be
ashamed of who they are" and so she agreed to
appear on Blunt - a teens' TV programme. But an unfortunate result
of outing
herself so publicly was that neighbours now knew that she was a transsexual, and
people shouted
abuse at her in the streets.
Céline Van Den Bossche |
Whilst at primary school, Van Den Bossche knew that he was
different from the other boys. He began wearing make-up and
dressing as a girl. When age 15, she transitioned, adopted the the forename Celine and began female hormone treatment. Age 18, she
underwent a sex change operation and was now legally a woman in
Belgium. Four years later she was working as a hairdresser
and in all aspects of her life was living as a woman. Perhaps
unwisely
she entered and won a local beauty contest. As a result, she
qualified for the Miss Belgium contest and strong local
support made her one of the
favourites. However, a reporter from Laatste Nieuw did
some research and interviewed her just before the contest, in answer to a question she
admitted
"I'm transgender, so what?". Now out'ed, she was
a shock elimination in the preliminary round.
Teddy
Quinlivan (shown age 21) was a top-100 female model when she outed herself as a transsexual. Her limited breast
development drew no attention; indeed she was used as a body
model for store mannequins! |
Other major risks are involved with trying to go partially
stealthy, e.g., going "stealth" at work but "out" with friends and
family. Inevitably this division will not work long term.
Confiding one's transsexuality to a partner or best friend with an
oath of secrecy is extremely risky - human nature being what it is
the word will almost inevitably slowly spread. The temptation to reveal one's background in order to get a job,
obtain a bank loan, to explain odd results in a medical, etc., is also often great, but
again this breaks the stealth rules and increases the risk of
eventually being publicly out'ed.
Actresses Harley Wittmer and Josie
Totah on their graduation day at Chapman University in June
2022. |
Stealth in Public
An increasingly common occurence is successful transwomen who have
been out'ed or don't hide that they are transgender, but whom the media gives up on
headlining as being "trans" because it's become boring and no longer
newsworthy. After a few years this leads to the situation
where if the woman is passable, people forget that she's transgender
and assume that she's a cis-woman. In the UK, topless
model Larissa Summers and actress Talisa Garcia are examples of this
phenomonen. In the USA, a good example is
actress Josie Totah. She was born male but transitioned age
17. She has since had a very successful career as an actress, e.g.
she was cast as Mabel, an aspiring young American female socialite
(albeit bi-sexual) in the
period TV series Buccaneer.
A few other examples include American model Teddy Quinlivan, actress
Hari Nef, German pop-princess Kim Petras, Pakistani dancer Rimal Ali and
British business woman Reece Tomlinson.
Marriage
and Children
A huge pressure faced by stealthy and physically passable transwoman in their 20's and 30's is
to marry. The vast majority do indeed marry a
man but they then face intense pressure to have children - with
constant hints and reminders that the biological clock is
ticking and that they need to have children before it's too late.
A still from the film Carlotta, Carol with
her future mother-in-law expressing her hope that she will soon be a
Grandmother. |
The Australian film Carlotta -
based largely on the autobiographies of pioneering transwoman
Carol Byron-
includes a study of how her marriage was
destroyed by her mother-in-law's expectation of grandchildren.
She had SRS in 1971 but her autobiographies may not fully document
this period of her life and it's unclear how accurate the film is.
One speculation is that in 1975 she met and married in London a man
with the surname Spencer whilst stealth, she certainly used the name
Carol Spencer for several years thereafter.
In the 1970's and
1980's a stealth transwoman could claim that she was infertile
due to an unstated medical condition, and this would be accepted.
However, advances
in medical science mean that trying to make such a claim in the
2020's will instead lead to "helpful" suggestions of
various tests and treatments.
When transwoman Carmen Carrera married her boyfriend, she became the stepmother of his two
daughters from a previous marriage. |
Given the current impossibility of bearing children, push-back
reasons and excuses can include:
1. I don't want children. Whilst this may
cause arguments with a husband who wants to be a father, it's a clear
cut reason that also justifies the taking of
'contraceptive pills'.
2. I want a baby but no luck so far. A very
credible excuse for transwoman over age 35, but if the husband
is determined to have children then seeking fertility medical advice
is likely to be suggested and will need to be avoided.
3. I've had a miscarriage. A fake pregnancy and
early miscarriage can be a credible and traumatic excuse, but if
repeated will be problematic.
4. I'm infertile. Once the golden ticket, it's
now the last resort as details will be sought and medical
treatments suggested.
In
2015 the
Argentinean model Nicole Ferri
appeared in the short film Panza ('Belly Bump' in English), a
documentary of the true-life story of a young woman who was
faking being pregnant in order to get the attention of a
bank security guard but was then shot when the bank was
robbed. Nicole is
shown using pillows to create a baby bump and whilst a subtitle
makes clear that she's an actress, it's not stated that she is a pre-SRS transwoman.
This documentary is presumably the source of
re-occurring claims that
Nicole is a mother. |
Women Incorrectly Outed
Spanish actress Antonia San Juan is
a cis-woman, but often identified as transgender because of her
role in the 1999 movie All About My Mother. |
The spotlight of even modest fame and publicity is
fatal for most transwomen attempting
to go stealth. It
quickly out's most transwomen, even if they later claim that
they weren't really trying to go stealth.
Many more (from Caroline Cossey to Harisu to Nikkie de Jager)
realise that they are about to out'ed and pre-empt this publicly.
There are also a few transwomen such as Teddy Quinlivan, Sophia Hutchins,
Tatjana Wiedemann, Geena Rocera and Marie France who chose to out themselves as transgender
after years of successfully passing as a woman. This may
still leave some
well know women who have successfully concealed being transgender,
but it's unlikely that many would be considered an A or B list
celebrity.
Conversely, some genetic cis women celebrities have been incorrectly outed as being transgender. In
some cases this is undoubtedly
deliberate "false news" aimed either harming the recipient in some
way or raising the profile of the poster.
Attorney, author and commentator
Ann Coulter.
Her Adams Apple is oft quoted as evidence that she is
transgender. |
One example is the popular
American political pundit,
Ann Coulter. In 2005 there began a determined attempt to expose her as a transsexual woman, or
perhaps a
suffer of AIS.
A leading speculation claimed that she was
born Arthur Coltrane in Georgia (USA) and had SRS in Denmark as a
teenager. A host of circumstantial evidence was offered to
prove that she was once "male", e.g. that she is: 6ft tall; has brow
ridges; an Adams Apple; big hands; big feet; has not been forthcoming
with her childhood records; her age varies oddly in interviews; and her birth certificate has never been published. However, many years of determined
investigation ultimately failed to provide any strong evidence that
Ann is transgender (e.g. photos of her as a boy), if she is actually a
transsexual then she has taken going 'stealth' to an impressive
depth.
.
Lady Gaga with a penis in her panties? Almost certainly no. |
In December 2008
photos of pop singer Lady Gaga during a concert were posted on the internet
that appeared to show the outline of a penis, leading to suggestions that she
was a pre-op transsexual woman or hermaphrodite. The most likely explanations are that she had a sanitary pad in her
pants, or that she has an unusually large clitoris and
was sexually aroused at the time of the photos.
Lady Gaga
then stoked the speculation
that she
transgender for over a year - all publicity is good publicity!
But in 2010 she appeared
in a very revealing music video (Bad Romance) and another video (Telephone)
that made fun of the idea.
Eventually
photos emerged of her posing naked, the photographer - Steven Klein
- stating "there were rumours that Lady Gaga was trans or
something. It was fun to poke at those rumours". This ended the debate - except for some
who believe
that she had belatedly spent some of her fortune on radical feminisation surgery
of her bottom genitalia.
Another singer-musician claimed to be a transsexual
is Avril Lavigne, very oddly due to her brother (Matt). He
said in 2012 and again in 2015 that when their mother (Judy) became pregnant with Avril, their
violent father insisted that it must be a daughter. The newborn baby was
however a boy, but Judy dressed and brought up Avril
as a girl, eventually even giving her female hormones. This improbable story
is slightly supported by
some circumstantial evidence:
Avril Lavigne.
Despite her brothers claims it seems unlikely that she's
transsexual |
-
Avril reached the age of 39 with no children
from two marriages and several serious relationships
-
Her short height (5ft 2in) is actually compatible with taking
excessively large dosages of oestrogen hormones at a young age
-
The length of her fingers are more typical of a
genetically XY male than a XX female
-
She has had extensive plastic surgery, aka
facial feminisation surgery. Her
nose, chin and jaw line have all changed substantially compared to a more robust appearance in
her early teens
-
Before
having breast augmentation, Avril posed
topless for several photo shoots and her small breasts with small
areola, were typical of a young transwoman
Nevertheless, it seems very unlikely that Avril is
transgender.
The most notorious example of a genetically XX woman being mistakenly
outed as a transwoman is Miss France 2001 -
Elodie
Gossuin, a saga which deserves its own
article.
Unfortunately
many transwomen give themselves away with silly and careless
mistakes, particularly when tired or after a drink. I've
made mistakes that have had me cringing and worried for days. |
Going Stealth
- My Comments
After
I transitioned in my mid-30's I hated the feeling of being constantly under examination by everyone
(even family) as a transsexual woman. My body, hair, appearance,
manners, make-up, voice, movements ... I knew that they were all up
for discussion when I was not about.
I tried to avoid telling people about my past, but I
found that sometimes I had to admit to my male past, or I was asked revealing questions, or I was simply "outed".
Thus an ever growing number of people got to know - my family, my
doctor, my bank, my closest friends, my boss, my work colleagues,
their acquaintances, .... .
I was
(and still am) uncomfortable about people knowing and talking about my past,
which was rapidly becoming distant and irrelevant to me.
I started to dream
about going "stealth" and live completely as woman
without anyone knowing my past, but while this is an appealing
prospect in many ways, it would also be extremely difficult to
achieve. Going stealthy to that extreme would imply me being
absolutely convincing as a woman at all times, have no contact with
people (including family) who know me otherwise, and destroy all
evidence (photo's, school reports, references, letters...), of my
previous incarnation. It would also mean fabricating a complete
and believable past (including girlhood) covering the time before I
transitioned, obtaining all the essential supporting documentation,
and then completely and utterly maintaining the story at all times.
I would also have to somehow remove all evidence of myself from the
Internet.
A few personal
experiences of just how hard passing and stealth is
to achieve, and how embarrassing failure can be:
-
Whilst visiting my mother I went out to get some groceries. I was shocked when a
shop assistant recognised me - we had been in the same class at
college. I was trying (and
obviously failing) to pass as a woman.
-
Post-transition I had
my car stolen by 'joy riders'. The car was recovered the next
day but the Police were confused as the records they checked didn't match
my new name. I had a
very awkward interview
before I could reclaim the car.
- I became friends with
a girl and we started to go to the local swimming pool every Sunday. After a few weeks she
told me that I needed to hide my penis a bit better.
- I arrived at an airport in the Arabian Gulf when still pre-GCS,
and unfortunately aroused suspicions when I reached the Customs
Area. I was taken to an interview room where I was strip
searched and left wearing only my panties (no bra). A senior
officer finally arrived to approve my release - apologetic but
with a smile on his face.
- During the 1980's I worked at a university for several years and occasionally met
the young wife of one of the lecturers. In 2002 I was
surprised to get an email from her. She had amazingly found and recognised me in some online photos and revealed that she was also transgender.
Asian transsexual women such as
Makiko Tsutsui (a minor TV celebrity in Japan) tend to be remarkably
passable in western eyes because
of their small stature and light build, often
greatly assisted by early transition. |
A few years after my transition I was delighted to discover that I
had become able to pass consistently as a woman. But this then created
the problem of
keeping separate family and friends who knew that I
was a transwoman from new friends and acquaintances who assumed that I
was a cis-woman.
I had also gained a very determined boyfriend
and was
suddenly facing increasing pressure to marry
him! I was being given reminders
from the uninitiated [usually married]
that
my biological clock was ticking and that I should have children
before it was too late.
I've since been seeking a compromise
degree of stealth in my normal daily life and with the
passage of time I believe that I'm now near finding
this. I suspect that a key factor is that after over 20 years transitioned, so few of
my family, friends and acquaintances have never met me
except as Annie. This includes my once boyfriend
and now husband.
It was thus a shock when recently a woman I was
working with asked if I was "trans". I reluctantly said yes, and
she explained that I had some similarities with her transitioned
brother, now sister, that had made her start to wonder.
A
Survey
The
Connectivity newsletter of
FORGE
(For Ourselves: Reworking Gender Expression), a male-to-female support
organisation, conducted a
survey
about the extent to which its members felt that they were perceived
(or out'ed) as male or female, and the associated context.
I've taken the liberty of summarising the report as follows:
1 = Male by everyone, 5 = Female by everyone.
|
1 |
2 |
3 |
4 |
5 |
Employment |
25% |
8% |
41% |
10% |
12% |
School |
15% |
2% |
7% |
12% |
2% |
Family |
5% |
8% |
3% |
22% |
58% |
Social Clubs |
14% |
2% |
29% |
22% |
25% |
Acquaintances |
17% |
12% |
29% |
25% |
10% |
Friends |
2% |
14% |
10% |
19% |
53% |
Note: The totals don't add to 100%,
particularly for 'School', the survey says "Figures
for those out at school are too small to analyze."
Presumably the gap reflects where no response was selected.
Unsurprisingly a majority of participants
felt that they could pass as female with friends and family,
but very few were confident of this at work or with
acquaintances. Excluding 'School', just 10% of
respondents that they could pass as female in all
situations, and this was probably an exaggeration.
Many transwomen convince themselves that they can pass until
a traumatic event proves otherwise. As noted several
times elsewhere on this site, passability is brutally age
dependent - whilst many teenage transgirls can pass easily
with just hormones, transwomen in their 20's, 30's and beyond
rely increasingly heavily on feminising surgery and the
reality is that a majority will never consistently pass
successfully.
Contestants in a Miss Trans beauty contest
The "Can I Pass?" Quiz
Two
Brazilian shemales sunbathing nude on the beach - very
passable as women if you ignore
their penises (pixalated). |
I've
seen several quizzes on the Internet about "passing".
Unfortunately, these seem to be mostly concerned with transvestites
attempting occasional passing in public, so I thought I would have a
go myself at a quiz for pre-transition, adult (age 18 or older),
transsexual women who are considering going full time. The quiz
is designed to give some indication of the chances of being quickly
"read", it gives less indication about the chances of
passing long-term when many other factors come into play.
This
quiz is primarily intended to be for fun, but also a little
thought provoking for pre-transition girls. Please don't take it
too seriously and shoot me down in flames, but I do welcome
constructive feedback and
suggestions that will help me refine it.
It
you really want to try the quiz, it's here.
|